98 points, James Suckling, Oct 2018, Top 100 wines of 2018
94 points, Wine Advocate Robert Parker, August 2019
“From the oldest part of the Rippon estate vineyards. Significant vines for anywhere, really, when you consider the context and impact of Rippon. This is the most brooding, dark fruited and spice-laden Tinker’s I have seen.Quite brutish in a way, but not untoward, just heftier, lumbering, palate sticking, dense than this wines has been for me before. Dark chocolate, clove and cinnamon characters mesh with a thick weave of emery board tannins. The wine is all dark fruit, mocha, earthiness and toasty wood characters, quite lavish, shades of midnight for pinot noir, very long in flavour, expressive and guttural. It’s quite beguiling in its way, though get set for the atypical expression.”– 93 Points, by Mike Bennie Winefront